Do we need to revamp how we provide escort reviews? Or is it just me?

[iamsploot]

Maybe I’m the only one that feels this way, but can we rethink the layout of the escort reviews section?

I enjoy reading reviews for various providers but...

Maybe I’m the only one that feels this way, but can we rethink the layout of the escort reviews section?

I enjoy reading reviews for various providers but there are a slew of providers with a lot of reviews form the same client. No shade, I love that ocbusinessman and swiftly (or whatever it is haha) are living my dream life but it’s not really all that helpful to have so many reviews of a provider from the same client, such as with Raina Rae and Alexis James (Tryst Agency) etc. I’ve seen Daisy Stone and Ashley Fires (Alluring Intros) way too many times and don’t feel like I need to continually provide reviews of the escapades as a couple are enough insight into the experience.

I still think these additional reviews provide valuable insight but is there a coding guru here that can have these additional reviews be updated to existing reviews? Is there a way to have these additional reviews ladder up to the provider in a collapsed view?

Maybe it’s just me and I’m a minority in this, and if that’s the case then ignore this and carry on. FYI I’m not calling these contributors out cuz I’ve read all their reviews

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Swytypy]

Swiftly?

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[iamsploot]

Swiftly?

I had to go off memory and then autocorrect got me

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[oc.businessman.33]

Maybe I’m the only one that feels this way, but can we rethink the layout of the escort reviews section?

I enjoy reading reviews for various providers but there are a slew of providers with a lot of reviews form the same client. No shade, I love that ocbusinessman and swiftly (or whatever it is haha) are living my dream life but it’s not really all that helpful to have so many reviews of a provider from the same client, such as with Raina Rae and Alexis James (Tryst Agency) etc. I’ve seen Daisy Stone and Ashley Fires (Alluring Intros) way too many times and don’t feel like I need to continually provide reviews of the escapades as a couple are enough insight into the experience.

I still think these additional reviews provide valuable insight but is there a coding guru here that can have these additional reviews be updated to existing reviews? Is there a way to have these additional reviews ladder up to the provider in a collapsed view?

Maybe it’s just me and I’m a minority in this, and if that’s the case then ignore this and carry on. FYI I’m not calling these contributors out cuz I’ve read all their reviews

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[iamsploot]

I’m your huckleberry

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[drlove69]

You know what I hate about the reviews? People that type up 10 and 20 year old experiences as new. It's just not relevant and factual.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[zm7000]

I’m with @iamsploot when he says:

Is there a way to have these additional reviews ladder up to the provider in a collapsed view?

I liked how the old site used to just have the reviews grouped per girl. The UI was nice. Just a picture of the girl and when clicked you could see all the reviews by date and member. I know the site is shit but TER does it this way as well, minus the pictures.

Just my two cents. I’m not a review guy, however I think this interface is a bit cleaner than it is now

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Swytypy]

As long as any revamp that takes place doesn’t lose all existing reviews, I’m cool with anything the hive mind comes up with. I know the last time the section was revamped, all of the reviews were lost. I have my own copies of mine, obviously, but I know some other people just type theirs in here and don’t have backups.

Plus, all of the conversations that have taken place on the reviews either add a ton of value to the conversation or add humor or both.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[zm7000]

As long as any revamp that takes place doesn’t lose all existing reviews, I’m cool with anything the hive mind comes up with. I know the last time the section was revamped, all of the reviews were lost. I have my own copies of mine, obviously, but I know some other people just type theirs in here and don’t have backups.

Plus, all of the conversations that have taken place on the reviews either add a ton of value to the conversation or add humor or both.

Totally forgot the last overhaul cleaned out the reviews from before. That wouldn’t be good

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Townbizz54]

Swiftly?

Better than swipity

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Townbizz54]

if all reviews are 5 stars then what’s the point.
Part of the reason I don’t waste my time writing them anylonger is 50% is bull shit that’s either exaggerated or a complete lie
4 stars isn’t bad. It just can be a warning that hey, this is how it went down for me, be aware.
Now days everyone puts 5 star everything and that’s simply impossible to be accurate, girls have an off day, people don’t click, shit happens, but being unwilling to right an honest review because you’re afraid that you’ll get black listed over it is exactly why people need to start writing real reviews
Redvook and the erotic review were the gold standard, when we lost those and private delights was basically the only option it ruined the review game cus if you say anything negative the admins won’t approve it

This site kinda does a good job with allowing honest reviews but still two many people don’t say the truth


That’s my two cents.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Townbizz54]

Maybe I’m the only one that feels this way, but can we rethink the layout of the escort reviews section?

I enjoy reading reviews for various providers but there are a slew of providers with a lot of reviews form the same client. No shade, I love that ocbusinessman and swiftly (or whatever it is haha) are living my dream life but it’s not really all that helpful to have so many reviews of a provider from the same client, such as with Raina Rae and Alexis James (Tryst Agency) etc. I’ve seen Daisy Stone and Ashley Fires (Alluring Intros) way too many times and don’t feel like I need to continually provide reviews of the escapades as a couple are enough insight into the experience.

I still think these additional reviews provide valuable insight but is there a coding guru here that can have these additional reviews be updated to existing reviews? Is there a way to have these additional reviews ladder up to the provider in a collapsed view?

Maybe it’s just me and I’m a minority in this, and if that’s the case then ignore this and carry on. FYI I’m not calling these contributors out cuz I’ve read all their reviews

Btw it’s sweetiepie… took me a minute to figure it out too lol

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Townbizz54]

Also. Yeah 1 review per girl per year should be a standard… by 3 or 4 we get it but that’s not going to be the same as experience as a new clients,

The rest should live in the swipity chronicles and the businessman journal (copyright)

And I get the desire to right the details of each date and I’m sure there are some who enjoy reading those details, but the review aspect is redundant

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[Townbizz54]

As long as any revamp that takes place doesn’t lose all existing reviews, I’m cool with anything the hive mind comes up with. I know the last time the section was revamped, all of the reviews were lost. I have my own copies of mine, obviously, but I know some other people just type theirs in here and don’t have backups.

Plus, all of the conversations that have taken place on the reviews either add a ton of value to the conversation or add humor or both.

Seriously not knocking the content, I’m sure there’s a way the powers that be can add something to profiles and all the longer follow up stories can live there…

And there’s definitely something to be said about developing chemistry with a provider that you won’t get out of date 1 or 2

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[pescadodiablo]

I don't see how having multiple reviews of the same girl does any harm to anyone. If you see multiple reviews and don't want to read them all, look up the latest one and move on. Honestly if you see multiple reviews of the same girl by the same user, you don't even need to read the review to know they think highly of her.

I appreciate every review on this forum, whether it pertains to a girl I'd be interested in or not. I appreciate even more so the effort folks like oc.businessman.33 and swytypy take in crafting their reviews that go above and beyond the standard.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[lvg99]

I don't see how having multiple reviews of the same girl does any harm to anyone. If you see multiple reviews and don't want to read them all, look up the latest one and move on. Honestly if you see multiple reviews of the same girl by the same user, you don't even need to read the review to know they think highly of her.

I appreciate every review on this forum, whether it pertains to a girl I'd be interested in or not. I appreciate even more so the effort folks like oc.businessman.33 and swytypy take in crafting their reviews that go above and beyond the standard.

This. No different than any other thread on the forum. If you don't have an interest in reading something skip it. I enjoy reading Swytypy's and OC's repeat reviews.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[JHartshaw]

You know what I hate about the reviews? People that type up 10 and 20 year old experiences as new. It's just not relevant and factual.

I stopped just because of complaints like yours.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[iamsploot]

This. No different than any other thread on the forum. If you don't have an interest in reading something skip it. I enjoy reading Swytypy's and OC's repeat reviews.

Reviews of the same provider isn’t the problem, it’s reviews of the same provider by the same clients. Sure there might be some different service but it doesn’t seem to be the case from what I’ve read. Two reviews of the same provider by the same client is fine, but more than that I dunno if it’s warranted. Like do I really need five reviews or Alexis James (Tryst Agency) from swtypy in a 6 month span? Doubt it unless one of them early on was terrible, which wasn’t the case.

But that’s why I suggested a ladder, or allowing edit/updates to existing reviews.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[lvg99]

Reviews of the same provider isn’t the problem, it’s reviews of the same provider by the same clients. Sure there might be some different service but it doesn’t seem to be the case from what I’ve read. Two reviews of the same provider by the same client is fine, but more than that I dunno if it’s warranted. But that’s why I suggested a ladder, or allowing edit/updates to existing reviews.

But what I'm saying is why does it even matter? Just don't click on a thread you don't want to read. There are threads on here about BBW that I have less than zero interest in. I just don't look at them. I don't care if someone posts a review of the same girl 20 times or a review from 20 years ago. If I want to read it I will and if I don't it doesn't mean anything to me. More available knowledge is never a bad thing.

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.

 

[iamsploot]

But what I'm saying is why does it even matter? Just don't click on a thread you don't want to read. There are threads on here about BBW that I have less than zero interest in. I just don't look at them. I don't care if someone posts a review of the same girl 20 times or a review from 20 years ago. If I want to read it I will and if I don't it doesn't mean anything to me. More available knowledge is never a bad thing.

I guess for me it’s causing more to scroll/click thru, but that’s why I recommended laddering/collapsing being and elegant solution that doesn’t limit lots of reviews of the same person/client. Or maybe we just made a sidebar penthouse forum for our two hall of fame clients

Upgrade your account to unlock this section.